Actually just watched Disc 2, the Tampa Bay game an hour ago. Giant fans need to add this to their collection.

This is a basic, unspectacluar package that showcases nothing but the games. You get all the playoff games, plus the NE loss in week 17 that propelled them into the playoffs. Moral victory indeed...

I wish these games were presented in widescreen format. The pan and scan format is disappointing, but I'm so happy to just have these games on dvd. Perhaps a Blu Ray down the line? Strahan's SB commentary insightful, funny. Left me wanting more special features though.

I read a lot of the reviews on here, about how bad the quality is, and this and that, whatever. I ordered and received it the next day. I raced home after work to put it on - The first disc, Giants Vs Pats in the regular season, I wasn't too fond of. First of all it was on the NFL Network, That's a laugh. The commentator's were terrible.
The quality, of course, is not in HD or anything, but it's still watchable.
Overall, this is a remarkable thing the NFL is doing. I didn't see 3 out of 5 of the games available, and it was great to finally see what I missed.
This is clearly a must have for ANY Giants fan; Regardless of HD quality or not.